Can We Really Trust The Bible?

can we really trust the bible? C4L Connect4Life

Can We Really Trust The Bible: Reliability & Relevance

God’s Word – reliable, relevant and life-changing.

Have you ever wondered how we can know the Bible is trustworthy?

It’s an extraordinary collection of 66 books, written over approximately 1,500 years, by around 40 different authors, from different backgrounds and in different circumstances. Yet it tells one remarkable, connected story: God’s relationship with humanity, His rescue plan through Jesus Christ, and His invitation for us to know Him.

But how did these books come together? Who decided what belonged in the Bible? Were the writers eyewitnesses? And can we really trust that what we read today is what God intended us to hear? Here, we’re answering a commonly asked question: can we really trust the Bible?

Can We Really Trust The Bible?


Let’s explore!

1. The Old Testament – God’s story begins

The Bible didn’t suddenly appear as one complete book.

The Old Testament developed over many centuries. Its books were written by prophets, leaders, poets and historians, including Moses, David, Solomon, Isaiah and many others.

The Jewish Scriptures were traditionally grouped into three sections:

– The Law (Torah): The first five books, beginning with Genesis, revealing God’s creation, covenant and commandments.
– The Prophets: God’s messages to His people, calling them back to Him and pointing towards His purposes.
– The Writings: Including Psalms, Proverbs and other historical and wisdom writings.

By the time of Jesus, these Scriptures were already recognised and used as God’s authoritative Word.

Jesus Himself regularly quoted them. When tempted in the wilderness, He responded with Scripture: ‘It is written…’ (Matthew 4:1–11).

On the road to Emmaus, Jesus explained to His disciples what was written about Him throughout the Scriptures (Luke 24:27).

The Old Testament isn’t an outdated collection of religious stories. It lays the foundation for understanding Jesus, God’s character, our need for salvation and His promises.

2. The New Testament – eyewitnesses of the risen Christ

The New Testament emerged from the extraordinary events surrounding Jesus’ life, death and resurrection.

The four Gospels – Matthew, Mark, Luke and John – give us accounts of Jesus’ life and ministry.

Matthew and John were among Jesus’ apostles. Mark was closely associated with Peter, and Luke carefully investigated the accounts passed on by eyewitnesses.

Luke begins his Gospel by explaining:

‘Many have undertaken to draw up an account of the things that have been fulfilled among us, just as they were handed down to us by those who from the first were eyewitnesses and servants of the word.’ (Luke 1:1–2)

Luke wanted Theophilus to know that he had carefully investigated the events and could have confidence in what he had been taught (Luke 1:3–4).

Peter also makes the point that the apostles weren’t simply inventing religious stories:

‘We did not follow cleverly devised stories when we told you about the coming of our Lord Jesus Christ in power, but we were eyewitnesses of his majesty.’ (2 Peter 1:16)

The resurrection was central to their testimony. Paul, writing to the Corinthians, records that the risen Jesus appeared to Peter, the Twelve, more than 500 people, James and finally Paul himself (1 Corinthians 15:3–8).

These weren’t simply people passing on an interesting philosophy. They believed they had encountered the living, risen Jesus – and many were prepared to suffer for that conviction.

3. Peter – the rock and the apostolic foundation


Jesus asked His disciples:

‘Who do you say I am?’

Peter answered:

‘You are the Messiah, the Son of the living God.’ (Matthew 16:15–16)

Jesus responded:

‘And I tell you that you are Peter, and on this rock I will build my church.’ (Matthew 16:18)

Peter became a leading apostolic witness, preaching boldly about Jesus’ resurrection and helping establish the early Church (Acts 2).

He also wrote letters to encourage Christians to stand firm in their faith, grow in godliness and remember the truth they had received.

The apostles’ teaching was foundational to the early Church (Ephesians 2:20).

The important point is that Christianity wasn’t built on rumours, changing opinions or one person’s interpretation. It was rooted in the teaching and testimony of those commissioned by Jesus.

4. How did the New Testament books get chosen?

This is where an interesting piece of Church history comes in.

As Christianity spread, different churches shared the accounts of Jesus and the letters written by apostles and their close associates.

Paul’s letters were circulated between churches and read aloud in their gatherings (Colossians 4:16). Peter even refers to Paul’s letters alongside other Scriptures (2 Peter 3:15–16).

Over time, Christians recognised a collection of writings as carrying apostolic authority and faithfully communicating the truth about Jesus.

The early Church considered important questions:

– Was the writing connected to an apostle or an authorised apostolic witness?
– Did it agree with the faith and teaching handed down from Jesus and the apostles?
– Was it recognised and regularly used by churches across the Christian world?
– Did it bear the character and authority of Scripture?

This was a process of recognition over time, rather than one individual deciding what everyone should believe.

What about the Council of Nicaea?

You may have heard that the Bible was put together at the Council of Nicaea in AD 325, with church leaders deciding which books to include and which to exclude.

That’s a common misconception!

The Council of Nicaea did not decide the biblical canon. Its main concern was defending the truth about Jesus’ identity, particularly against teaching that denied the full divinity of the Son of God.

The Council affirmed the belief that Jesus Christ is truly God, not a created being, and produced the foundation of what became known as the Nicene Creed.

The recognition of the New Testament books was a much longer process. An important milestone came in AD 367, when Athanasius listed the same 27 New Testament books that we have today. Regional Church councils subsequently affirmed this collection.

The Church didn’t make these books God’s Word; it recognised the authority that Christians believed they already carried.

5. What about the Apocrypha?

You might have noticed that some Bibles contain additional books, sometimes called the Apocrypha or Deuterocanonical books.

These include Tobit, Judith, Wisdom, Sirach and 1 and 2 Maccabees.

These writings are important historically and can help us understand Jewish life, beliefs and history in the period between the Old and New Testaments.

However, Christian traditions differ over their status.

Protestant Bibles generally follow the Hebrew Old Testament collection of 39 books and don’t treat the Apocrypha as part of the inspired canon.

Roman Catholic and Eastern Orthodox traditions include additional books in their Old Testament collections, although their exact collections differ.

The important distinction is that not every ancient religious writing automatically carries the same authority as Scripture.

For example, there were other early Christian writings claiming connections with apostles, such as the Gospel of Thomas. The early Church examined such writings and did not recognise them as part of the New Testament canon.

We shouldn’t assume that something is true simply because it is old, religious or mentions Jesus.

6. All Scripture is God-breathed – not just the bits we like!

Perhaps one of the most important verses for understanding why we can trust the Bible is:

‘All Scripture is God-breathed and is useful for teaching, rebuking, correcting and training in righteousness.’ (2 Timothy 3:16)

Notice that Paul says ALL Scripture.

The Bible isn’t a pick-and-mix collection where we can select the comforting promises and ignore the challenging commands.

We can’t embrace God’s love but reject His holiness. We can’t celebrate forgiveness but ignore repentance. We can’t accept the blessings while dismissing the call to obedience.

Of course, we need to read Scripture in context, understand its original audience, recognise different literary styles and consider how the whole Bible fits together.

Some passages describe events; others give commands, poetry, prophecy or wisdom. Not every instruction given to an individual in the Bible is automatically a direct command to us today.

But we must never make ourselves the final authority over God’s Word.

Hebrews 4:12 tells us that God’s Word is ‘alive and active’ and able to penetrate our hearts and reveal our thoughts and attitudes.

The question isn’t simply whether we agree with everything we read.

The question is whether we are willing to let God change us through what He says.

7. So, can we trust the Bible?

We have good reasons to approach the Bible with confidence:

– Its books have been preserved and passed down through generations.
– The Old Testament provides the foundation for the New Testament and points towards Jesus.
– The New Testament records the testimony of those who encountered Jesus and the risen Christ.
– The early Church carefully examined and recognised the writings that formed the New Testament.
– Its central message is consistent: God loves us, humanity needs rescuing, Jesus is our Saviour, and we are invited into relationship with Him.

Ultimately, trusting the Bible is more than winning an argument about historical documents.

It is about trusting the God who speaks through His Word.

Jesus prayed to the Father:

‘Sanctify them by the truth; your word is truth.’ (John 17:17)

And He promised:

‘Heaven and earth will pass away, but my words will never pass away.’ (Matthew 24:35)

8. What does this mean for how we live?

If we really believe the Bible is God’s Word, it should make a difference to our everyday lives.

Read it: Don’t rely solely on what someone else tells you. Make time to discover God’s Word for yourself.

Study it: Ask questions. Look at the context. Explore difficult passages. Don’t be afraid to investigate.

Live it: Allow Scripture to shape your decisions, relationships, priorities and behaviour.

Share it: The Bible isn’t just for our own encouragement. It’s good news to be shared with others.

Worship through it: Let God’s truth inspire your praise, prayer, gratitude and obedience.

And when we come across something challenging, rather than immediately dismissing it, let’s ask: ‘Lord, what are You teaching me? How do I need to respond?’

YOUR C4L CHALLENGE

This week, why not try something different?

1. Read 2 Timothy 3:14–17 slowly.
2. Choose a book of the Bible you’ve never read properly and start exploring it.
3. Write down one thing God is teaching you.
4. Identify one way you can put that truth into practice.
5. Share something you’ve discovered with someone else.

And remember: don’t just read the Bible to find something that agrees with you. Read it with a heart that is willing to be changed by God.

The Bible isn’t simply a book to be read. It’s God’s Word to be lived!

A FINAL THOUGHT

We live in a world full of competing voices, opinions and claims about truth.

But God’s Word gives us an unchanging foundation.

Let’s be people who know what we believe, understand why we believe it, and have the courage to live it out.

Don’t just take someone else’s word for it. Open the Bible, discover God’s truth and let it transform your life.

WORSHIP SONG FOR REFLECTION: ‘Speak, O Lord’ by Keith Getty and Stuart Townend –

YouTube player

A wonderful song that asks God to speak through His Word, shape our hearts, renew our minds and help us live in obedience.

A fitting prayer as we seek to trust, understand and live out the Bible.

‘Speak, O Lord, as we come to You, to receive the food of Your holy Word.’ 

FURTHER READING: Should we read the Bible literally or contextually? | C4L

Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *